Every experiment on a tumour line needs a comparator. Without one, a difference in proliferation, migration, or drug sensitivity cannot be attributed to a property of the cancer rather than to the peculiarities of a single culture. The lines in this catalogue — respiratory, hepatic, renal, thyroid, breast, ocular, prostate, and fibroblast/adipocyte models — are the non-tumour or immortalised "normal" counterparts most often used for exactly that purpose. The essential caveat runs through the whole list: almost none of these is a truly normal cell. Immortalisation, long-term culture, and clonal selection alter the genome, the transcriptome, and the phenotype, and a normal-tissue line is a convenient approximation, not a physiological reference.
Respiratory and airway epithelium
- BEAS-2B — normal human bronchial epithelial cells immortalised with an SV40/adenovirus-12 construct; the standard non-tumour comparator for lung carcinogenesis, oxidative stress, and airway-inflammation studies. It retains a near-diploid karyotype but is immortalised.
- 16HBE14o- — a human bronchial epithelial line used for tight-junction and epithelial-barrier (TEER) experiments because it forms polarised monolayers with functional CFTR. Valuable wherever an intact airway barrier is required.
- MH-S — an immortalised mouse alveolar macrophage line, used for lung innate-immunity and phagocytosis work as the mouse counterpart to human macrophage lines.
- NR8383 — a rat alveolar macrophage line, the classic non-human model for pulmonary macrophage activation and particle toxicity.
- MLE-12 — a mouse lung epithelial line derived from SV40 large-T immortalisation of distal respiratory epithelium; used for alveolar type II cell biology and surfactant studies.
Liver and kidney
- L-02 (HL-7702) — a human hepatocyte-derived line widely used in Chinese laboratories as a "normal liver" comparator for hepatotoxicity and drug-metabolism studies.
- QSG-7701 — a human hepatocyte line from normal liver tissue, used alongside L-02 for hepatocellular toxicity and virology.
- HK-2 — an immortalised proximal-tubule epithelial line from normal adult human kidney, immortalised by HPV-16 E6/E7; the main human renal-toxicity comparator and a model for tubular transport.
- OK — the opossum-kidney line used as a non-human renal epithelial model, notable for its use in transport and viral studies.
Thyroid, breast, ocular, and prostate
- Nthy-ori 3-1 — a human thyroid epithelial line immortalised with SV40 large T; the standard non-tumour comparator for papillary and follicular thyroid carcinoma lines.
- MCF-10A — a spontaneously immortalised, non-transformed human breast epithelial line; the reference "normal breast" comparator against MCF-7 and MDA-MB-231, and a model for acinar morphogenesis in three-dimensional culture.
- ARPE-19 — a human retinal pigment epithelial line used as the non-tumour model for the blood–retina barrier, oxidative stress, and ocular inflammation.
- Ishikawa / HEC-1-A — human endometrial epithelial lines used as comparators for endometrial cancer and for hormone-response studies; both are long-established and karyotypically abnormal.
- RWPE-1 — a human prostate epithelial line immortalised with HPV-18; the standard non-tumour comparator for LNCaP, PC-3, and DU145 prostate cancer lines.
Fibroblasts, adipocytes, and embryo models
- NIH-3T3 / BALB/3T3 — contact-inhibited, non-tumorigenic mouse embryo fibroblast lines; the standard "normal" fibroblast comparator and a transformation assay substrate.
- 3T3-L1 — a mouse fibroblast subline that differentiates to adipocytes with a standard insulin/dexamethasone/isobutylmethylxanthine cocktail; the workhorse model for adipogenesis, insulin signalling, and lipid metabolism.
- BJ / HSF — normal human diploid fibroblasts (BJ from foreskin, HSF from skin) used as primary-like non-immortalised comparators and for replicative-senescence studies.
- MEF — primary mouse embryonic fibroblasts, the near-diploid non-transformed reference used for reprogramming, senescence, and knockout studies; they have a limited lifespan.
- V79 — a Chinese hamster lung fibroblast line used widely in mutagenicity, chromosome-aberration, and cytotoxicity testing.
- CHO — the Chinese hamster ovary line; the dominant mammalian expression platform and a standard karyotypically unstable non-human comparator.
How these controls are used in practice
The choice of control depends on the question. For a cytotoxicity or drug-sensitivity comparison, the control is a non-tumour line of the same tissue and species, so that a shift in IC50 can be attributed to the tumour rather than to the tissue of origin: BEAS-2B against A549, MCF-10A against MCF-7, RWPE-1 against LNCaP, HK-2 against renal carcinoma lines, Nthy-ori 3-1 against thyroid carcinoma lines. For a transformation or carcinogenesis assay, the control must be contact-inhibited and non-tumorigenic, which is why NIH-3T3 and BALB/3T3 are standard. For barrier and transport studies the requirement is functional differentiation — 16HBE14o- forming tight junctions, ARPE-19 forming a polarised retinal monolayer, HK-2 retaining tubular transport — and a merely viable line will not do. For differentiation or metabolism work, pre-adipocytes (3T3-L1) and diploid fibroblast strains (BJ, HSF, MEF) serve as the physiologically responsive reference. In every case the control is matched to the readout, and the comparison is only as good as the match.
The caveat: many "normal" lines are not normal
- Immortalisation is a transformation event. SV40 large T, HPV E6/E7, and similar agents inactivate p53 and RB, so the cell has already bypassed two central tumour-suppressor pathways. BEAS-2B, HK-2, RWPE-1, Nthy-ori 3-1, and MLE-12 are immortalised, not normal.
- Karyotypic and phenotypic drift. Long-term passage selects for growth-advantaged subclones; CHO and many established lines are markedly aneuploid, and marker expression drifts.
- Origin matters. Some lines derive from tumour or virus-transformed tissue despite being labelled "normal"; the L-02/HL-7702 nomenclature and the Ishikawa/HEC-1-A pair are repeated examples of ambiguous provenance.
- Use the right comparator. A normal-tissue line should match the tumour in species, tissue, and, where possible, differentiation state; comparing a lung tumour line against a kidney control confounds the comparison.
- Authenticate. STR profiling and mycoplasma screening apply to controls as much as to tumour lines, because a contaminated or misidentified control silently invalidates the whole study.
References
- Ryan MJ, Johnson G, Kirk J, Fuerstenberg SM, Zager RA, Torok-Storb B. HK-2: an immortalized proximal tubule epithelial cell line from normal adult human kidney. Kidney Int. 1994;45(1):48–57. doi:10.1038/ki.1994.6
- Puck TT, Cieciura SJ, Robinson A. Genetics of somatic mammalian cells. III. Long-term cultivation of euploid cells from human and animal subjects. J Exp Med. 1958;108(6):945–956. doi:10.1084/jem.108.6.945
- Green H, Kehinde O. Sublines of mouse 3T3 cells that accumulate lipid. Cell. 1974;1(3):113–116. doi:10.1016/0092-8674(74)90126-3
- Wikenheiser KA, Vorbroker DK, Rice WR, et al. Production of immortalized distal respiratory epithelial cell lines from surfactant protein C/simian virus 40 large tumor antigen transgenic mice. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 1993;90(23):11029–11033. doi:10.1073/pnas.90.23.11029
- Burns JS, Lemoine L, Lemoine NR, et al. Thyroid epithelial cell transformation by a retroviral vector expressing SV40 large T. Br J Cancer. 1989;59(5):755–760. doi:10.1038/bjc.1989.158
- Callaghan PJ, Ferrick B, Rybakovsky E, et al. Epithelial barrier function properties of the 16HBE14o- human bronchial epithelial cell culture model. Biosci Rep. 2020;40(10):BSR20201532. doi:10.1042/bsr20201532
- Azari S, Ahmadi N, Tehrani MJ, Shokri F. Profiling and authentication of human cell lines using short tandem repeat (STR) loci: report from the National Cell Bank of Iran. Biologicals. 2007;35(3):195–202. doi:10.1016/j.biologicals.2006.10.001